The ATO has been sending some mixed messages
about property development involving an SMSF and has indicated that it is one of the issues on its radar for 2018. So is property development an allowable investment for an SMSF? The short answer yes, but be careful. A longer answer is cautious — it is straightforward to trip up and breach one or other rules. The ATO is keeping an eye on this and will scrutinize any fund utilizing property development.
SMSF Property Development – The Risks
The first problem you face is that in operating a property development, you will likely be engaging in business activity. While the law does not explicitly prevent an SMSF from running a business, the ATO has been evident that while it may be allowed it is frowned upon due to the possibility of the fund straying from working for a “sole purpose,” and will likely lead to greater scrutiny.
The ATO has warned that when reviewing the carrying on of a business in an SMSF, it will be on the lookout for:
the trustee employing a family member (it looks at things such as the stated rationale for using the family member and the salary or wages paid)
the business carried on by the fund having links to associated trading entities
there are indications the fund’s business assets are available for the private use and benefit of the trustee or related parties.
The next problem you face is the trust deed. Most first trust deeds would not have envisioned running a business and even some newer ones as well. The law is apparent that the trust deed must specifically allow for this — mere silence on the subject is not enough. Therefore, have your trust deed reviewed and updated if necessary. This is a legal document so you will need to get a lawyer to look at it or get a commercially available one.
You will also need to review your investment strategy. While this need not explicitly spell out that it includes property development, it would be a good idea to update it to reflect this option. It will also be prudent to review your risk appetite — property development is inherently risky, and this should be reflected in the member risk profile in the investment strategy.
If the investment uses the assets of all members, then you should also have a note setting out that the members agree to this form of investment.
Payments to Members or Related Parties
A superannuation fund is expressly prohibited from providing non-retirement benefits to members and related parties. The legislation prevents a trustee of an SMSF from giving financial assistance to members or relatives of members. Therefore if a member of the fund or a relative (possibly including “associates”) receives a benefit from the fund in the form of payments towards the costs of the development, there is the potential for there to be a breach of compliance requirements.
Financial assistance will not be deemed to be provided if the member or a related party is paid market rates, however, if underpayment is charged then there is likely to be a form of financial assistance that breaches the rules.
Consideration must also be given to the requirement that prima facie prohibits an SMSF from acquiring assets from related parties. This becomes very difficult for a fund when engaging a pertaining party to undertake the development. The SMSF rules permit the payment to a related party for “services” related to property development but prohibit building materials to be bought from a related party as these are assets of that related party.
One solution to this is for the SMSF to enter into an “agency” or “reimbursement” agreement with the related builder that states that the builder is not buying the material for themselves (and therefore becomes their asset) but on behalf of the SMSF. Again this must be crafted properly, and you can still run into the problem of the “arm’s-length” requirements.
Even where your dealings with related parties are permissible, they must always be at arms-length prices. Part of the reason for doing the development in-house rather than getting an external provider may be that it is hopefully cheaper to do so. However, if payments are under or over market prices, then there will be a breach of these requirements. Therefore it is essential that such transactions are well documented, and that proof exists of payments at market rates (it may be a good idea to get third-party quotes as proof).
When dealing with property development at non-market rates there is another potential issue to contend with — payment considered to be a contribution. The relevant legislation says: In the superannuation context, a gift is anything of value that increases the capital of a superannuation fund provided by a person whose purpose is to benefit one or more particular members of the fund or all of the members in general.
Therefore, where services are provided below market value, this will in effect increase the capital of the SMSF, and can, therefore, be considered a contribution. The ATO also made it clear that where a related party improves an SMSF asset at no cost to that SMSF, to benefit the fund, this will constitute a contribution reflective of the increase in market value of the fund’s assets.
8 Steps to Take Before Entering Into a Property Development with Your SMSF
Step 1 – Review your trust deed. It must specifically allow for running a business. If it does not, update it.
Step 2 – Review your investment strategy. Is property development allowed? Is it by the risk profile of the fund? Does it benefit all the members?
Step 3 – Talk to this office about the right structure for your fund entering into property development.
Step 4 – Keep everything at arm’s-length and at market value; there are many pitfalls here so take care.
Step 5 – Don’t purchase directly from a related party, and make sure any related builder is buying on behalf of the SMSF or the unit trust.
Step 6 – Beware of borrowing rules as costs may blow out.
Step 7 – Make sure it is a good investment, don’t overpay, know the local market, and beware of market trends.
Step 8 – Finally, document everything. The ATO has this on its radar, so expect greater ATO scrutiny if you engage in property development through your SMSF.